The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum (http://forum.barrowdowns.com/index.php)
-   The Books (http://forum.barrowdowns.com/forumdisplay.php?f=9)
-   -   Did Frodo and Gandalf actually meet before Bilbo and Frodo's party? (http://forum.barrowdowns.com/showthread.php?t=15496)

TheGreatElvenWarrior 05-27-2009 10:35 AM

Did Frodo and Gandalf actually meet before Bilbo and Frodo's party?
 
I don't know why I haven't thought of it before, but I was confused after I pondered it (This is one of the things I do before I go to sleep at night, pondering Tolkien). It has been bugging me for some days now and I cannot seem to find the answer.
It appears that Frodo and Gandalf have meet before September of Frodo's 33rd year in the Peter Jackson film because it seems that they have been united after a long absence of each other (well, that's what I always thought). The radio plays give me the same impression. But when I read my books, it does not seem so. It looks as if Frodo has been informed about Gandalf but not actually met Gandalf.

I guess what I am trying to get out (because my thoughts when I get them down on paper (or the screen) seem to be a bit hard to follow) is did Frodo meet Gandalf before the month of Bilbo's 111 party?

Any thoughts?

Hakon 05-27-2009 12:10 PM

I do not think so. The way I always viewed it was that Frodo had heard all about Gandalf from Bilbo but never actually met him until the party. I had the same impression with Bilbo meeting Gandalf back in the Hobbit. The way it is written makes it sound like both had heard all about Gandalf, mostly his fireworks and they both met him after hearing all about him.

Annunfuiniel 05-27-2009 12:24 PM

Quote:

They knew him by sight, though he only appeared in Hobbiton occasionally and never stopped long;
The hobbit children knew Gandalf by sight so I deem he had been there more than once even during their lifetime. And Frodo had lived at Bag End for about 12 years by the time of The Party so he would definitely have met Gandalf at least couple of times. Maybe their acquaintance deepened into true friendship only after Bilbo's departure and Frodo's coming of age. Knowing Frodo had his rascal period while in his tweens (and earlier; referring to farmer Maggot and his mushrooms :)) I can well imagine what might have happened if Gandalf let his fireworks unguarded:

*KA-BOOOOOM!!*

"Fool of a Baggins!"

Sorry.... :D

The Might 05-27-2009 05:27 PM

Yes, they very surely did, as this quote from the Thain's Book encyclopedia points out:

Quote:

Bilbo and Frodo had a comfortable life at Bag End, a spacious Hobbit hole under the Hill in Hobbiton in the Westfarthing. Bilbo had once gone on an adventure and had returned with wealth and knowledge of the world outside the Shire. Frodo learned much from him about the peoples, legends, and languages of Middle-earth. Gandalf the Grey was a frequent visitor at Bag End, as were a number of Dwarves, and it was believed that Frodo would sometimes meet Elves in the woods of the Shire. For these reasons, Frodo was considered quite unusual for a Hobbit.
I'll also try to find a quote in the books that supports the quotation above.

Hakon 05-27-2009 07:27 PM

Apparently I was under the wrong impression for quite a while. Now I feel quite stupid.

Did Gandalf ever meet Bilbo prior to their meeting at the beginning of the Hobbit? I think that either Bilbo had met Gandalf once when he (Bilbo) was very young or he had never met Gandalf prior to that meeting. Bilbo talks about Gandalf as if he is someone Bilbo has not seen in years or someone he has heard a lot about but not met yet.

Ibrīnišilpathānezel 05-27-2009 08:22 PM

It's possible. Bilbo would have been a child (not a baby) at the time of the Fell Winter, when Gandalf "came to the aid of the Shire folk." I suspect, however, that any meeting that might have occurred would have been brief and comparatively insignificant. At the time of The Hobbit, it's clear that Gandalf had been observing Bilbo for some time (particularly from what I recall of the tale as told by Gandalf in UT). That Bilbo actually remembers the fireworks Gandalf made for the Old Took would mean that there was a possibility that they had met at some time prior to TH, but again, I suspect the meeting would have been casual, at best.

TheGreatElvenWarrior 05-31-2009 09:47 PM

So, more evidence points to Frodo and Gandalf meeting prior to the Party than evidence points to them not meeting it looks like.

narfforc 07-03-2009 12:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hakon (Post 598502)
Apparently I was under the wrong impression for quite a while. Now I feel quite stupid.

Did Gandalf ever meet Bilbo prior to their meeting at the beginning of the Hobbit? I think that either Bilbo had met Gandalf once when he (Bilbo) was very young or he had never met Gandalf prior to that meeting. Bilbo talks about Gandalf as if he is someone Bilbo has not seen in years or someone he has heard a lot about but not met yet.

In The Quest of Erebor, Unfinished Tales, Gandalf says of Bilbo "I had known him once very well, almost up to his coming of age, better than he had known me". He later goes on to say "I remember how he used to pester with questions when he was a youngster....".

Hakon 07-03-2009 02:59 PM

That is interesting. Almost like Gandalf decided to watch over him.

narfforc 07-03-2009 03:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hakon (Post 602533)
That is interesting. Almost like Gandalf decided to watch over him.

Or was Gandalf MEANT to meet Bilbo. That is way fate seems to work in Middle-earth.

TheGreatElvenWarrior 07-06-2009 04:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by narfforc (Post 602538)
Or was Gandalf MEANT to meet Bilbo. That is way fate seems to work in Middle-earth.

Didn't Gandalf tell the hobbits that him meeting Bilbo and the Dwarves were chance meetings? I don't have my copy of UT with me, so I couldn't find the passage...

Hakon 07-06-2009 04:52 PM

No I think Gandalf told the hobbits that his meeting the Dwarfs was a chance meeting and meeting Bilbo was not.

narfforc 07-06-2009 04:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hakon (Post 602879)
No I think Gandalf told the hobbits that his meeting the Dwarfs was a chance meeting and meeting Bilbo was not.

That's correct, his meeting with Thorin Oakenshield was a chance meeting on the edge of spring, not far from Bree. At that point he'd already met Bilbo.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:48 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9 Beta 4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.