Hard question, I have never been in love, so if I was to make my decision now I would go and live forever, just because I like life and that would be great to have eternal life.
Even though Arwen was happy for a small amount of time, she still had a terrible death. She was all alone wondering around Middle Earth. Luthien had a much better time, she and Beren (according to what is in the Silmarillion) basically died at the same time. Arwen and Aragorn had a period of time where Arwen had to be alone. I would not want that to happen, and if I had choose mortality that would be one time that I would probably reconsider my decision. So I would probably choose just to go with eternal life, it is not that I am a romantic or anything.
[ February 05, 2003: Message edited by: Gorwingel ]
__________________
Wanted - Wonderfully witty quote that consists of pure brilliance
|