The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - A Ride to the Dark Side--Discussion Thread

Lugbúrz · 01-19-2003, 08:13 AM

I see. I did not expect the chase to go so far south before crossing the Anduin.

This only presents more problems. Osgiliath, though in ruins wasn't free to pass for the enemy. It was held strong until the War of the Ring. The Anduin represented an ultimate defense in Gondor that was not breached right until the War of the Ring, when Osgiliath fell (the crossings fell a year prior to the War of the Ring, until when Gondor had full control and a very good watch on it, even then they held the near end of city right uptil the Batlle at the Pellenor) and so did Cair Andros.

Are you expecting the group to cross in extreme stealth despite such enemy territory?

Might I suggest an alternate path into North Ithelien, safely north near the mouths of the Entwash?

I just read Kiara's post. Very well written, but I believe her view of the 'bridge' is a little simplistic. There was no free passage. Can someone check this out?

I've decided to post tomorrow due to the uncertainity.

01-19-2003, 08:13 AM	#163
Lugbúrz Haunting Spirit Join Date: Jul 2002 Location: Middangeard Posts: 69	I see. I did not expect the chase to go so far south before crossing the Anduin. This only presents more problems. Osgiliath, though in ruins wasn't free to pass for the enemy. It was held strong until the War of the Ring. The Anduin represented an ultimate defense in Gondor that was not breached right until the War of the Ring, when Osgiliath fell (the crossings fell a year prior to the War of the Ring, until when Gondor had full control and a very good watch on it, even then they held the near end of city right uptil the Batlle at the Pellenor) and so did Cair Andros. Are you expecting the group to cross in extreme stealth despite such enemy territory? Might I suggest an alternate path into North Ithelien, safely north near the mouths of the Entwash? I just read Kiara's post. Very well written, but I believe her view of the 'bridge' is a little simplistic. There was no free passage. Can someone check this out? I've decided to post tomorrow due to the uncertainity.