The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post

Bill Ferny · 03-21-2003, 08:28 PM

There does seem to be a learning curve when it comes to magic. However, only select few with an innate, perhaps otherworldly, predisposition toward magic can learn the craft. You are right, PanMan, that there is no conclusive evidence based on the Silm’s description of the Nazgûl. Those of sorcery powers could have been Black Númenóreans possessing that predisposition as did the Witch King. Juxtapose this with the common perception of occult type magic, such as voodoo, modern day witchcraft, and New Age “powers” that can be achieved by anyone who has the right formula or the proper tarot deck or stands in the right place.

Once again the examples sited exemplify the craftsmanship model of the old alchemy mythologies. These characters learn magic and incorporate magic much like a craftsman, most notably the smith and metallurgist.

Minas Morgul College (MMC for short)… bah. Good basketball team, but lousy football. I matriculated from UEI (University of Espionage, Isengard) and we spanked them every year (orc-men linebackers, you know).

03-21-2003, 08:28 PM	#58
Bill Ferny Shade of Carn Dûm Join Date: Aug 2002 Location: Bree Posts: 390	There does seem to be a learning curve when it comes to magic. However, only select few with an innate, perhaps otherworldly, predisposition toward magic can learn the craft. You are right, PanMan, that there is no conclusive evidence based on the Silm’s description of the Nazgûl. Those of sorcery powers could have been Black Númenóreans possessing that predisposition as did the Witch King. Juxtapose this with the common perception of occult type magic, such as voodoo, modern day witchcraft, and New Age “powers” that can be achieved by anyone who has the right formula or the proper tarot deck or stands in the right place. Once again the examples sited exemplify the craftsmanship model of the old alchemy mythologies. These characters learn magic and incorporate magic much like a craftsman, most notably the smith and metallurgist. Minas Morgul College (MMC for short)… bah. Good basketball team, but lousy football. I matriculated from UEI (University of Espionage, Isengard) and we spanked them every year (orc-men linebackers, you know). __________________ I prefer Gillaume d’Férny, connoisseur of fine fruit.