[Esgallhugwen]

I couldn't really say what Frodo would do seeing as i am not him, but he might choose to be immortal. But that brings up the point of the anniversary (if you will) of when he was stabbed by the Morgul blade and when he was bitten by Shelob, on those days he experiences great pain and misery, or would that happen when he went to Valinor? Would the Valar relieve him of his anguish? Would he be too overwhelmed by the beauty and peace there to linger on those harse thoughts..hopefully so, because I feel that's why he went there in the first place. As for Bilbo he is quite aged but perhaps he would want to live at least a few more years among that land. Gimli i'm really not sure about I don't know much about Dwarve kind, but he is a very good friend with Legolas so perhaps he would not want to part with him or perhaps he would choose his mortality so he could be with his anchestors. The Valar are merciful and kind, I truly think that they would allow the mortals to stay in Valinor although mortality was a gift of Iluvatar, so they mey not bring up that decision, seeing as it is most likely beyond their hands.