Hmmm.... This is an interesting thread...
As Legolas said:
Quote:
Oh? And killing your own kindred for their ships is "realistic"? Would you murder your uncle to use his car to drive after a thief? If the thief was the Devil himself? Surely not.
|
Feanor was a bad man... He was self important in a way. I feel he was kind of obsessed. He wanted to be the best.
And I don't see why he wasn't willing to give the Silmarills to Yavanna. If Feanor had said yes to give them to her, he would do something for all of them, in Beleriand and Middle-earth. Not just himself. (I know Morgoth took them at that time, but Feanor didn't know that. I hope that made sense) That was soooo stupid off him.
And go killing his friends for boats?? What was that dude thinking? (Am I sensing some boat obsession too?) And I think the worst of all is: that he burns the ships. Fingolfin was nice to him. I think that Fingolfin actually respected him. And that was a huge deal. After all, Feanor had never been nice to Fingolfin.
Feanor had no moral, that's why I think he is self-important. He really doesn't care about others. Just his treasures...
I am not sure anything of this made sense... Just feels good to express my "hatred" against Feanor... [img]smilies/wink.gif[/img]
*Nova, the Feanor "hater".. hehe
(Okey then, I do not hate him, he just annoys me..)