I am not saying that it shouldn't have been have been the third marriage of elda and man because of impurities, but because Arwen isn't an elda, let alone an elf to begin with. I remember a discussion on Arwen's elfishness before Elrond left for the West and I thought a consensus was reached that at no time was Arwen truly an elf or a human, until her final decision when she became human.
|