The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post

Son of Gondor · 01-02-2002, 10:39 AM

I also was surprised by how Elrond was portrayed. I could hardly keep from whispering something about Mr. Anderson to my friend beside me. We both agreed that we thought he looked different. I always thought he was large and fatter (If elves can get fat) But I thought he did a good job as Elrond. Hugo won me over. And I just found it neat to see him in the thousands of years old battle and then see him in Rivendell, looking the same.<BR>The role that I thought was not well done was Galariel. I found myself wishing both times I've seen it that the Company should just start sailing their boats down the river already. Maybe that was how the book made her, but she was too weird and talked in that odd voice. It made her more eiree than beautiful.<BR>Everyone else I thought was well cast. But why do you think they never showed a good picture of Gollum?

01-02-2002, 10:39 AM	#3
Son of Gondor Pile O'Bones Join Date: Dec 2001 Posts: 13	I also was surprised by how Elrond was portrayed. I could hardly keep from whispering something about Mr. Anderson to my friend beside me. We both agreed that we thought he looked different. I always thought he was large and fatter (If elves can get fat) But I thought he did a good job as Elrond. Hugo won me over. And I just found it neat to see him in the thousands of years old battle and then see him in Rivendell, looking the same.<BR>The role that I thought was not well done was Galariel. I found myself wishing both times I've seen it that the Company should just start sailing their boats down the river already. Maybe that was how the book made her, but she was too weird and talked in that odd voice. It made her more eiree than beautiful.<BR>Everyone else I thought was well cast. But why do you think they never showed a good picture of Gollum? __________________ Have pity on poor Boromir, for to see the white tower fall would see the despair of men.