The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - How it should have been...Purist universe.

Amaranth Sorrel · 01-26-2002, 04:45 AM

in response to lomion's comments, i don't mean to sound mean or anything, i'm also just giving opinions.<BR>i can totally understand where you're all coming from with your views, so dont worry <BR>I actually saw the film first, which some fans find annoying and all i have to say to them is, at least i know their names, know the full story and respect & love it for what it is. Three truly amazing books.<BR>I don't actually agree that Elrond was ugly in the film... I thought he was okay. <BR>Who do you reckon should have played him then?

01-26-2002, 04:45 AM	#20
Amaranth Sorrel Pile O'Bones Join Date: Jan 2002 Location: Yorkshire, UK. Posts: 22	in response to lomion's comments, i don't mean to sound mean or anything, i'm also just giving opinions.<BR>i can totally understand where you're all coming from with your views, so dont worry <BR>I actually saw the film first, which some fans find annoying and all i have to say to them is, at least i know their names, know the full story and respect & love it for what it is. Three truly amazing books.<BR>I don't actually agree that Elrond was ugly in the film... I thought he was okay. <BR>Who do you reckon should have played him then? __________________ -Amaranth "For mine is the choice of Lúthien."