Your arguements all seem valid and well thought out everybody. But I'm surprised to hear that none of you mentioned that when Aragorn led them to attack the the cosairs of umbar Legolos mentions that the sea was awakening in him and it was the first time he saw it.
Now when the arguement is stated that Legolos died in the fall of Gondolin and later came back to middle earth he would of crossed the sea. So that arguement should be put to rest right then and there. But as for the whole age of Legolos that is for all these Tolkien message boards to argue over for years to come.
|