Tuor was made immortal by Eru. Whether the Valar wanted him in Aman or not, he was there because the big man said so.
I doubt Ulmo would've been bothered by men or dwarves in Aman. He didn't live there. About the Valar wanting men and dwarves in Aman - maybe not. They didn't want Sauron to rule Middle-earth either, though. They would've had to done something about it, if not take in the mortals.
That being said, what do you think about the possibility of history repeating itself?
Similar to how Ulmo brought the Teleri to Mana, another island is made for the dwarves and men and moved to Aman, or at least a distance from Middle-earth.
Maybe this new island, or the men/dwarves stay in Aman, would be temporary, while the armies of all the good races battled Sauron.
[ January 30, 2003: Message edited by: Legolas ]
__________________
...take counsel with thyself, and remember who and what thou art.
|