[dancing spawn of ungoliant]

I think that the Shire was great... also 1 but I got a nice picture of Bree when I read the book- in the film it was too unfriendly. Men were rude to hobbits but it was described to be a place where hobbits and men live in harmony! That makes it 5. I liked Rivendell very much though it didn't look like anyone's home (compare the film to the description given in the Hobbit). I'd give 2. the Orthanc IS awesome... can't believe that the Numenorians built it. Moria is great...dark but great...2. Lothlorien could have been more faithfull to the book. It would have been great to see the golden leaves still gets 3 (and the thing with the gifts- I mean Sam gets a rope?! *huh*) but great job! Can't wait RotK!