[The Saucepan Man]

<BLOCKQUOTE>quote:<HR> I thought it was at the Pelennor Fields <HR></BLOCKQUOTE><P>No, if Aragorn says the whole speech, then it is at the Black Gate. For it is at the Black Gate that we see him saying "This day we fight!".<P>Now, in the interests of fairness, I feel that I ought to share this piece of evidence, even though it goes against my argument. While, Christmas shopping ( ) this weekend, I picked up one of the RotK picture books. And it gave a quote which suggested that "This day we fight!" is part of the rest of the speech. And it was on the page dealing with the Black Gate, rather than that concerning the Pelennor.<P>All of which would suggest that Aragorn makes the entire speech. <P>Stubbornly, though, I will ask the question that occurs to me. How much can we rely on these picture books?