[Lord Elrond]

I thought it was done pretty good as a whole. If I were to criticize it I would say that too much of the upper levels were harmed. In the book it was primarily just the lower level and the second lowest level. Too many bad guys made it into the city itself and the overlook was not supposed to be on the seventh level the precipice they looked off of to the gates below was on either the third or fourth I cant remember which. The same thing with the Rath Dinen it was not supposed to be on the seventh level nor was the beacon.but all in all it was very enjoyable