Hmmm. When Arwen's role was changed by PJ into a powerful, proactive one, there was a huge outcry from Tolkien fans. When her role was changed by PJ into a sickly one - no outcry. <BR>I didn't mind the Eldarion vision, although both that, and the back story from the Appendix in TTT, could have been brought in without all this will she/won't she go to Valinor. But I really disliked the mysterious sickness, and popping out from behind a banner like the lady sawed in half, ta-da, and the big smooch at the end. Can you imagine Tolkien's Aragorn and Arwen doing tongues in full view of all their subjects? Never!
__________________
Out went the candle, and we were left darkling
|