[Knight of Gondor]

I think a cloud would have worked, maybe better than the exploding eyeball. (Insert Ben Stein monotone: "For red, dry eyes, try clear eyes!" Mouth of Sauron: "Wooooow.") I think it would have been good if the shadow had sort have formed and perhaps reached a hand down, ala the prologue of Sauron reaching down to Isildur. But, the movie was what it was, and I still loved it.