Best Digusting Makeup Worn by a Good Character: Frodo, during the Flight to the Ford, FOTR
Most Obvious Line: Legolas, ROTK.... "A diversion!"
Worst Pseudo-Jewelry Commercial: Legolas and Aragorn's reunion, TTT- "You're late. You look terrible. Here. Have a girly necklace."
Best Range of Looks, Stares, Frowns, Scowls, Grins, and Winces: Sean Astin, in the role of Sam, o' course!