Indeed. Smith, LOTR, Beowulf, etc.
Just as each of the participants in the (old) eucatastrophe thread had experienced unique, individual eucatastrophes at varying points of the story-- which, IMO, would have been a *very* tall order for Tolkien to have pre-planned each of those one by one.
Which is why rather than constructing an allegory with preplanned (hopefully revelatory and not constricting) constructions, Tolkien wanted to "just tell a story", and let the reader break through where he was Supposed To.
Another way to say it might be, so that the reader is pulled through when he is ready.
__________________
...down to the water to see the elves dance and sing upon the midsummer's eve.
|