[Ruler of the Frogs]

I think that the matter that no woman would want to join the Fellowship should also be taken into account. There are exceptions, like Eowyn, but don't you think that in those times, most women would be reluctant to go on a journey? Perhaps with other women yes, but with nine men? I don't think so. All these girls that pretend they are female members of the Fellowship (whether through fanfiction or roleplaying) neclect to think about some of the complications that a woman would face on a jounrey. Quests typically take more than one month, and everyone knows what comes once a month. Try having that and trampling through the wilderness with nine men. No thank you! It's just completely illogical to have a female in the Fellowship. Too many differences and difficulties.