I would love to have played either Prince Imrahil or Glorfindel. They would not really have looked like elves, dark curly hair, heavy across the shoulders....more like a tall hobbit than an elf lord or one with elven blood.
The Witch King would have been fantastic, the long cloak, heavy gauntlets....Mr Evil himself. Bill Ferney would also be my style, but again he did not put in much of an appearance save possibly being a 'random character in the background in bree'.
