[Reyna Evergreen]

Yay! This post is incredible, and I've been following it for some time and believe it is time for me to jump in.

A agree that Gimli was referring to their beauty as the two most beautiful parts of the day. Galadriel has fair complections, reminding him of the rays of light pouring from the heavens in the early hours of morning. Arwen's are more deep, reminding him of the mysteries locked in the darkness.

All signs point towards this, but I have a thorn in my foot. When was it decieded that Galadriel was Day, and Arwen was Night? (metaphoricly, always) Gimli and Éomund might have been discussing about their personalities aswell.

Arwen is light-hearted and loves to shine and be warm; reminding of the day. Galadriel's power runs deeper than most think, and he mind is cunning and sharp reminding of the night.

So that just gives more of a thought on how it could go both ways...