Quote:
But once the reader has experienced it, and is therefore expecting it, isn't it diminished the second and third etc time round?
|
Well, actually, the two parts of my previous statement were intended to be taken separately. The first part referred to the reader and the second to characters in the story.
I suppose in re-reading the readers experience might diminish but the reader can obviously re-read a particular passage as often as possible.
The part about not happening the same way twice is specifically intended as a comment on the construction of the story itself.
Quote:
And if, each time, a Gollum popped out of a crevice and somehow vanquished Grendel, Grendel's mom, and the dragon-- then it would be repetitive, going against Tolkien's "Never to be counted on to recur." Am I getting close...?
|
Repetitive and strange.
Quote:
the horns of Rohan will never interrupt the Witch-King's speech at the gate again;
Sam will never see another star above the Ephel Duath that affects him quite like that one;
Aragorn will never unexpectedly unfurl his banner from a corsair ship again;
the Morannon will never fall again;
A wounded ringbearer-hobbit sailing west cannot be counted on to happen again;
...but we, in rereading these things, may still catch a glimpse of…evangelium
|
Yes, exactly.