|
HI Saucepan Man, If by her association with a mortal, Eru had decreed that she also was mortal, as in the case of Luthien and Arwen, then she would not have been allowed in. I know they both had to renounce themselves, but that was to be with the ones they loved, so it stands to reason that the same rules would apply to any of the elves. If Luthien who was also part Maiar could not go back, then why would they allow Mithrellas.
|