[The Saucepan Man]

Bumping this up for the post-RotK/RotK EE reaction.

Re-reading the thread, there are some interesting thoughts expressed both pro- and con- the films. It's a bit of a slog, given the formatting changes, but worth the effort. Hmm, perhaps I should heed HerenIstarion's advice and try tidying it up at some point.)

Given that the films still seem, on occasion, to generate strong feelings either way, I would be interested to hear further thoughts - from members new and old.