For the immense joy the reading through this thread brought me (especially, page 2, which I haven't read in its time after making silly joke on the page 1 I'm still tempted to delete but probably will let stand),
it goes up. Lure Fordim and davem into it, bring back Aiwendil and Mr. U (and Kalessin, Glenethor and Thingol if they reappear), spice it up with Bb, mark 12_30 and Child, stir the soup with the spoon of innumerable number of other thinkers these fora may be proud of and let's strike just another
Canonicity party!