I have balanced the suggestions in my mind. Here is what I have come up with:
Pros:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Fordim
we can't let the wolves hide either by casting meaningless votes in a landslide or abstaining
|
Cons:
The werewolves could vote in a landslide anyway. A landslide is still possible with a shortlist.
As Saucy said, there could very easily be no wolves in the shortlist - a chance of almost a quarter. This balances because overall the chances are the same.
The Werewolves could avoid the Shortlist by using how it works against the Villagers. They could, for example, vote against one another or for other innocent villagers (not in the landslide) to stay off the shortlist.
I would like Fordim to address all these issues, please, as well as the timing and place of his posting which I inquired about in an earlier post.