Quote:
I wish we hadn’t but I still think that The Phantom was a better choice than The Saucepan Man insofar as we will have the benefit of his more penetrating (and understandable) posts as we close in on the wolves.
-Fordim post #273
|
You seem convinced of his innocence. Why? His opinions are only of value if he is innocent and even if he is innocent he has been grievously wrong a number of times. Why are you so unwilling to consider the possibility of his guilt? You voted against him on the first day and have done everything possible to avoid it ever since. Estel’s theory becomes more appealing.
Quote:
Simply because I am convinced we have a better shot at bagging a Wolf. At this moment, I am convinced that at least two of the following are Wolves:
Oddwen
Holbytlass
Shelob
Azaielia
Even without working to narrow it down a bit more, that gives me a 50/50 chance of bagging a fuzzy.
-Fordim post #289
|
Hmm…so you say. However, I’ve re-read posts #273 and #282 and the feeling I get from them is hesitancy. (I know this must come as a shock to you). Particularly in post #282 I find your reasoning to be faulty because there is no way the werewolves could guarantee voting for the runners up everytime. This is particularly true if the werewolves try to split their votes to cover themselves.
I’m not at all disagreeing that there is probably at least one wolf in that group but I find your picking out Holbytlass and Oddwen from that group to be questionable.
Quote:
On the other hand, I can't imagine that there is any more than one Wolf among:
TORE
mormegil
Saucepan
Kuruharan
|
And you too for all we know. I’m not so sure about this idea.
Quote:
|
And I wouldn't be at all surprised if there were no wolves on this list!
|
I find this
very difficult to swallow. If we’d played about 20 games then I’d find this more credible. As it stands, I'm not going to base what may be the last day's voting on this (only a one in twenty chance of a random sample being screwy, in this case all loud males vs. all quiet females).