Quote:
Originally Posted by Shelob
...and then part of me says that this is too close to yesterdays Phantom/Saucepanman dilema for comfort...
I agree. The innocent Villagers should be considering everyone, not just two people. There are three Werewolves after all. But if it does come down to a decision between Kuru and me, I would obviously urge you to vote for him, given how sure I am about him now.
|
See my point? Look at what happened to the phantom and who was wrong about that.
Quote:
|
Well, he's got away with it so far.
|
Only because people are not willing to take me up on my offer, something I have no control over. I
want my theory to be put to the test. I
want to know if I'm right or wrong. Nothing would suit me better.
Quote:
|
You are clever enough to realise, Kuru, that the Werewolves killing strategy will change as the game progresses. Rarely can they afford to leave it static.
|
Hmmm...I fail to see the benefit to the werewolves to start killing at NIGHT people whose deaths would point to them. Call that silly if you wish, but...
Quote:
|
Then again, you weren't so keen to make this point yesterday when you accused me of implicating the phantom simply by virtue of defending myself.
|
That is because in general principle I don't so much have a problem with this. Today, I'm urging people to make a different choice than they did last time.
Quote:
|
In any event, it is not just the fact of someone defending themselves that makes them suspicious. The energy that they put into it and the prevailing attitude of the Village towards them at the time must also be taken into account. It is these factors which make your Day 2 behaviour very suspicious.
|
And in light of the experience we had with the phantom, I think this is an exonerating point in my favor.
Quote:
|
I would urge people to read all the posts, not just mine, take into account both arguments and form your own opinion.
|
Odd, so do I...
Quote:
|
You hardly give the impression of someone who thinks that he is wrong.
|
That is because I don't think I'm wrong. But I
have acknowledged the possibility that I might be and am willing to live with the consequences if I am.
Quote:
|
And in circumstances where the Werewolves have had virtually no votes cast against them (as is the case with you and mormegil, and probaly the third Werewolf too), the single-minded approach works well.
|
No, not really. The werewolves would want to preserve their numbers for as long as possible because it makes winning easier. Bringing suspicion down on themselves is not a good way to do this.
Quote:
|
So it's OK for you to admit that you might be wrong, but when I do it it's a ploy. Right.
|
That's just because of your status in the village (game).
