[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Well, Eomer, if you want me to address your comments, here I go.

As for being suspicious of you (by saying 'String her up!) that was in regard to the comment you made about the Seer being unimportant. That was a crazy thing to say.

I wasn't saying that the Seer isn't important. I was, and still am, saying that we don't need the Seer to win. What's important is innocent villagers that have some talent at picking out guilty faces, gift or not.

Fea, you seem to suspect littlemanpoet, phantom and myself simply because we have held correspondence with you, and thus natural suspicion had the chance to arise. The loudmouth effect.

You got it. Nobody else was making as much noise as us, so I felt obligated to pick my suspects from people who actually gave me some reason to feel that way.

If my points do not satisfy you then please explain how and why.

Whether I am satisfied or not, it is always good to have a public suspect. People get sloppy if they think your mind is set.