Hmmm. I think the phantom was kinda right. The werewolves might have tried to frame him and lynch him on Day 2, then when they couldn't do it, they killed him at Night. Why else wouldn't they kill him on Night 2 then, only to finally do him in the following Night? So maybe we should start looking at the way everyone voted. My theory is that last Day's events were an attempted lynching against phantom that got out of hand, because people somehow were more persuaded to vote against Eomer and Oddwen. I do suspect however that the last votes for Oddwen at the very end of the Day were placed in order to create the tie.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Fea
Either way, it's not reassuring.
|
Even less reassuring is you coming up with different suspects every day. That and the fact that on day 1 you told Eomer and phantom 'I hope you both die' and then, lo and behold...You're gonna tell me you didn't vote for Eomer on day 2, yes I know....Also, it doesn't look like you'll be voting for LMP on this one...
As for why I voted for Lalaith yesterday...
Basically I wanted to scatter the votes. And I wasn't convinced of either one's guilt (the phantom's or Eomer), so I didn't want to vote just to go along with the crowd. Most mistakes are made like that, as we all must realize by now.
At the moment I cast my vote, I could see two sides forming: pro phantom and pro Eomer. One of these sides was guilty, one was innocent. Or ironically they were both innocent, as I see it now, and the wolves were somewhere in the middle, laughing. As I couldn't tell which was which, I decided to select from my suspect list another name, in order to scatter the votes. This way, there was a bigger chance there was a werewolf on the lynch list.
Ironically, Oddwen was also on my suspect list, but as I went back to read through what she said, I realized I had ridiculously little against her.
I wanted to vote for someone who was on my suspect list and whose position I was not at all sure of. And if you want to know the reasons Lalaith was even on my suspect list, here they are: she seems a very logical and analytical person who nonetheless did cast a hasty vote for Kath on day 1 (ok, I know it was day 1 and all of us were dancing in the dark, but there were more suspicious characters than Kath around) , then even on day 2 she managed to work her way around arguments in such a way that I couldn't tell who she was suspecting, (which made her one of those 'grey' characters I mentioned as suspicious on Day 1. She said she would have voted for phantom but didn't, instead cast her vote for Oddwen to save Eomer whom she claimed she thought was gifted. But whatever reasons we all had to think Eomer was gifted, must have been disspelled by then, as no gifted one would go so aggresively after someone like he went after the phantom and Saurreg. Also, I wanted to see if she usually ignores her name coming up under suspicion, or she just made an exception when Eomer half jokingly accused her on Day 1. On Day 2 Lalaith somehow manages to create a tie between two innocents. Of course, she could argue that simply cross posting with Esga could mean she missed her post above, which is quite believable.
But why wait until the very end to cast your vote? And not to forget, I quite suspect Esga as well.
Also, there's something else I find unsettling about Lalaith: she keeps bringing into discussion the gifted villagers, in such a way, as if she expected us to point towards this person or that as being gifted, or to share our opinions of who is gifted and how. Not that innocent villagers are not allowed to wonder who the gifted villagers are, but are you willing to risk such information to be out in the open in order for you to have more certainty?