[littlemanpoet]

Originally Posted by Celuien

I wish I could pick up on guidance from the Seer, who must know something by now.

Everyone, open your eyes and read today's posts more carefully.

Originally Posted by Feanor

I've made my point about LMP and I'm watching happily to note that, yet again, nobody is paying any attention to it. Which makes me wonder.

Feanor, since you scream everything you say, over and over again, it gets easy for the rest of us to plug our ears, after a fashion. Maybe we shouldn't. On top of that, you contradict yourself. For example,

And did you truly take my words on LMP for serious? Remember that shortly after, I accused someone else, just for good measure, and in the same sentence, I accused three well-knowns not even playing? I was teasing, and the next paragraph actually said "No, in all seriousness..." Remember? I want to lynch ++ NILP for reasons already stated.

So, were you serious, or weren't you? Such contradictoriness tends to end up in unwanted deaths. When Nilp was contradictory about himself, he got himself lynched. You're contradictory, and wrong, about others, and you're getting a bunch of innocents lynched, saving your own neck. Some help. You're more harm to the village than good, I'd have to say. Which brings up the much needed question, are you an experienced villager, playing a brash, bold game of werewolf throwing the suspicion everywhere but home?

Now, even if I were a werewolf, which I'm not, so you can waste your useless vote on trying to lynch me, why on earth would I set you up, since you're an insufferable, screaming loudmouth who gets so focused on your own pet wrongheaded projects that you can't even STOP! to see the clear signs being laid down by your compatriots.

Two more things. You have been incomprehensible. Who can make sense of your diatribes? You lost me, except for the oen thing you're addicted to: "lynch LMP! lynch LMP! lynch LMP!" How could you expect any serious villagers trying to find the real werewolf to listen to you? Not to mention your bloodthirsty lust for lynching fellow villagers!

Okay, all insults duly posted, as requested.

Why then did the werewolves kill dancing spawn? Allow me to posit a few theories, since the wise amongst us will soon have placed their votes to lynch Hookbill.

To shut up the correct and/or dangerous.

First, let's distinguish between those lynched, and those killed. Since the villagers as guilty of the deaths of those lynched as are the werewolves, it's harder to be able to say much there. So let's concentrate on the killed.

dancing spawn voted for Esgal, who was a werewolf. She was correct. By all intents and purposes, it would seem that she made a lucky guess. So maybe there was another reason the wolves killed her. What might be a second possibility? Why do werewolves kill villagers, besides for hunger? There is the danger aspect. How could dancing spawn be dangerous to the wolves? Could it be that they thought she was the seer? After all, anybody who knows anything in this game knows that the werewolves would want to get the seer out of the picture, and everyone of us here knows that the seer is not yet dead. So spawn was correct about esgal, which might lead the werewolves to guess that she was the seer.

the phantom had a plan and was most arrogant about it, but his plan, had it been followed, would have served to foil the werewolves in their search for the seer. This was its strongest merit. He also showed great incisiveness in his reasoning. So perhaps he had a good chance of correctly deducing which amongst us are the werewolves.

Azaelia is still a puzzle to me. She showed no special aptitude outside the norm (which ain't bad at all, my friends ) . So I don't know. Correctness? Danger? Neither seems to have been in greater abundance than in any other villager.

All I can think of is one other possible motive, which, I believe, has been mentioned already, by phantom, I believe, which is that they are killing at random with no real logic to follow precisely to keep all of us innocents quite confused, at least until the seer picks the right "person" to dream about.

All this said, the people I'm pretty sure are not werewolves are Saurreg and Anguirel, which is a radical change from my position yesterday, but that's for you to figure out for yourselves. Lalaith still seems suspiciously tied to Eswen in getting Oddwen tied up with Eomer.