[Feanor of the Peredhil]

And one more night...

Originally Posted by Fea

tonight
Here are our options, and here is why each one should stay alive:

Holbytlass: She's our hunter. I'm quite sure of it. No point in having a wolf (presumably Kath) die along side her, when she doesn't need to die.

Gil-Galad: Perfectly innocent. We could kill him just for fun, but I've got a better idea.

Nilp: Same as Gil.

TGWBS: Perfectly innocent, but good at talking his way out of trouble. Unless the only one to suspect him (Firefoot) dies.

Firefoot: Also perfectly innocent, but very intelligent. Except for.. .you know... trusting me. That's just a bad judgement call on her part. Now listen: if we kill her off tonight, suspicion falls immediately to TGWBS, since she pointed him out today (I, of course, agreed with her).

If we kill off Firefoot, I'm still in the clear (why kill someone who trusts me?) and we can direct attention to TGWBS.

Worst case scenario: They don't go for it and Kath gets lynched. I'm still clear; Oro's still fairly clear.

Best case: it works, we win.

If you guys agree with me that Firefoot's our safest bet, than one of you needs to PM Mithalwen. I won't be back before tomorrow morning at the very earliest.

Originally Posted by Kath

I agree with Fea that we should kill Firefoot tonight. I will probably be lynched tomorrow no matter what but she is smart and suspected you Oro at the beginning. If we leave her alive much longer then with me out of the way she may turn back to you.

Obviously I'll do anything I can to get out of being killed tomorrow and if others start believing me it would be a great help if one of you two would support me in my campaign against TGWBS. Of course if I am basically being voted for from the first second then don't worry about it. I'll die!

Originally Posted by Oro

Firefoot is fine with me. Good luck tomorrow! Shall I go ahead and PM Mith then?

Originally Posted by Fea

Yes, PM Mith.

About TGWBS: I think it best if I lead the charge against him. Of the three of us, I'm the only one (God only knows how) that's avoided garnering any suspicion. Also, I've already stated doubts about him. I can subtley send out the idea and people will take me seriously. If Kath does it, they'll see "werewolf trick!". If Oro does, they won't know what to think, but they'll probably be sketched out. After it catches a little, if it catches, you guys jump in, but not to fast, savvy? I'd hate to lose the opportunity to win so cleanly and quickly.

If lynching TGWBS does NOT happen, Kath, you will likely die. I will not be trying to save you. I'm the "innocent" one, and I'm not keen on losing that status when it comes in terribly handy for swaying opinions ("Holby might be guilty on practically made up evidence that Fea had to scrounge to even find???! Let's change our votes!").

About Holbytlass: like I said, she needs to stay alive. If you check out voting patterns and statements, she's the only one that can be Hunter, whether she denies it or not. If I'm wrong, I can happily smack myself upside the head, but I doubt I am. TGWBS seconds my findings.

So if we kill Footie tonight, we've got a decent chance of taking out TGWBS tomorrow. Good luck, both of you. Here's a toast to our deceased comrade: go Morm! Way to die for the cause.