[The Only Real Estel]

Posted by lmp:

I was thinking that Morm was making some good sense, and thought I might vote for Durelin, but now it would be bandwagoning, and I hate bandwagoning!

Well, there is a huge difference between bandwagoning even though you suspect the villager to be innocent & adding your vote to the tally of a villager you suspect to be guilty.

Posted by Morm (on tgwbs:

His shop is a cobblers shop. He could be a wolf playing the cobbler but I think he's the cobbler. No sense in killing him until we don't know a wolf. But this would explain his weird and somewhat suspicious behavior. He's being a bit erradic

Posted by Lhuna (on tgwbs:

He might be a cobbler. If he is, he's doing a not-too-good job of hiding it, which, I believe, is actually the point of the role

That is a possibility, although I don't agree with Lhuna's summary of the role. I think the cobbler is supposed to be doing his best to confuse us, not just hide - remember wolves + cobbler= number of villagers does not mean the wolves win. And tgwbs is definitly not trying to hide very hard...

Posted by Morm:

Now having Lhuna post again makes me wonder about her. I don't believe her to be a wolf but her behavior is one that is consistent with a wolf trying to hide in the open. That could make her the cobbler or a wolf though I believe her to be neither

Lhuna I almost suspect more of being the cobbler than tgwbs or anyone else right now. She posts, not often enough to give us much to go on but she does post so that we won't lynch her on account of not posting. She acts as suspicious as she can without being to suspicious. This leaves us in the same spot as Nilp did, is she acting wolfish or is she wolfish? I would think this would be exactly what the cobbler would want us to be doing - having half of our attention on herself and half of our attention on the wolves.

While I am suspicious of Durelin it's more of a watch-&-see suspicion, I'm inclined to think like Eomer, she may be only a confused lass trying to help.

Kitanna is also on my watch list, along with morm, tgwbs, lmp, & Oromin. I'm not sure yet who I will vote for, like Eomer says, this round has not been as helpful as I was hoping.