[The Only Real Estel]

Posted by Kath:

With the innocence of E-W now proven I think that wilwa too may be innnocent as previously I had thought that they were working together and this is now obviously not the case.

I also thought they might've been working together, but I just want to remind everyone that it would be extremely easy for a wolf to 'go along' with an innocent in order to look innocent later. I am not extremely suspicious of Wilwa, but I think my point still bares keeping in mind.

Posted by Kath (about Eomer):

His track record so far has not been great with the deaths of a good few innocents under his belt, including I believe our guardian. I realise many of us were guilty of her death but I recall him being the leader of the mob and he seemed almost too contrite after her death.

Actually Eomer mentioned a suspicion of Oddwen & Kitanna, who we now know was a wolf, quickly jumped on that idea. I realize it might seem like I'm 'sticking up for Eomer' or whatever, but at this point in the, er...village, it's obviously vitally important to keep the innocent villagers around - & I am about 90% sure of Eomer's innocence.

By the way, don't forget about the Cursed Villager. The longer it takes to catch the wolves the better the chance they have of bolstering their ranks. Although at least we will know that 'no one was killed this night' means that there is another wolf, since our Guardian is dead.