[The Saucepan Man]

Originally Posted by dancing spawn

It's a shame that it was the wolf that killed Alcarillo because his death hardly leaves us any tracks to follow.

I presume that you mean arcticstorm. But that's rather a strange thing to say, isn't it? Not only is it stating the obvious - it's a shame when any innocent dies and moreso a Gifted - but we all knew that it was pretty likely to happen and we all knew that his death would leave few tracks because he declared himself the Shirriff fairly early on yester-Day.

With each post you make, dancing spawn, my hopes are raised that you may dispel my dounbts over you. And with each post you disappoint. You say very little to actually help us in our hunt for the lycanthropes. All that you have done today, other than mildly defend yourself and make assertions of the obvious, is agree with most others that LMP may well be the Cobbler. Can't you just tell us which way you are thinking with regard to the beasts? But now you have retired to bed without having done so.

Originally Posted by Gurthang

It is also unlikely they would not vote for their fellow at least once.

Given that the two Wolves that we have killed only voted twice between them, I would disagree. Also, the voting has been quite tight throughout most of each of the preceeding Days. I wouldn't be surprised if the remaining Wolf has never voted for a fellow Wolf. Once at most. Which points towards the bottom six on your list.

I also note that LMP and Durelin have not voted for a wolf, and I have supsected both of them before.

Neither has Laitaine. Why did you not mention her?

Why is there so little suspicion of Laitaine? Only SamwiseGamgee and I have expressed any serious doubts about her, although Menel gibbered vaguely about her. Am I missing something here? She is the only Villager who has voted suspiciously on every Day. Go on. Just look at her votes.

Of the three that I just named 'Slightly suspect', I am only slightly suspect because I have not suspected them before this. I'd be interested in hearing some more from them.

You want to hear more from me? Really? I would have thought that I have said more than enough already. Well, OK then. I am innocent. You should have figured out why by now.

I too was amused by LMP's rant. But it only serves to encourage my growing conviction that he is the Cobbler (I can hear his exasperated (but non-Wolvish) howl right now ). It's less the behaviour of a Bear, but it could be a double bluff. Anyhow, we should not vote for him today.

Right now, I am inclined to vote for either Laitaine or dancing spawn.