Quote:
|
First off, does this apply to all Men, or just Numenoreans?
|
I suppose it would. According what is said in Morgoth's Ring.
Quote:
|
Secondly, and (I think) more interestingly, we notice that many of the elves were not well-suited to live in Aman either.. that they revolted as well. Is there a connection here, by any chance? Are the Children of Iluvatar simply ill-suited for Aman on the whole? Is the desire for immortality on the part of Men simply one manifestation of this?......hmm.
|
An excellent question of course.
But you have to remember that when Feanaro revolted in Aman, there was the presence of Melkor that tainted Aman. Would they have revolted otherwise, i don't think so.
Men i think would ultimately envy the elves and Valar. Wouldn't you, if all of your neighboors and friends were inmortal and had inmortal joy.