It was a very well played game to everyone.
Despite your loss
Gurthang, I think you played the role well, there just wasn't much you could have done at the end. After Day 1 everyone just really assumed you were in character and were innocent. Well played, but with the nice plan
Saucepan came up with, it pretty much assured your loss. Still a well played game.
mormegil, thank you for the compliments.
Well my dreams went like this...The thing is it seemed like anybody I dreamed of that night who was innocent, ended up dying that night, so it never really benefitted me or the village at all...except
SpM that is.
Night 1-
mormegil, more of just a random pick and my small accusation of him during the day I never saw as progressing much.
Night 2-
Saucepan, I too got concerned as I saw him sort of taking control, just wanted to make sure what side he was on. Now, I wish I wouldn't have wasted that night, as I can see he left plenty of clues for his innocence, and the "Lets hunt some bear" that he was definitely the hunter. Well played Mr.
SpM
Night 3-
Gil-galad, if you notice the following day that was the only time I really made a suspect list. Because I had found
Gil-galad that night to be a wolf. Though I did start pinning people down to certain roles towards the end of the game, in the beginning I did not want to list suspects just in case if I would die, because for the first couple days I was not on to anything and did not want to lead people astray. Then I found of
Gil-galad's treachery, hence the first time making the suspect list.
Night 4-
Wilwarin, sadly she died that night, so again didn't benefit anything.
Night 5-
Nonnacedak, tried to save his life as he was going under suspicion, but I didn't want to draw too much attention to me as it could reveal who I was.
Night 6-
Durelin, this night I contemplated between Durelin and Gurthang, and wish I chose my second choice. As Durelin was the Cobbler, and Gurthang was the true one we were going for.
Night 7-
Meneltarmacil, he was really the most suspicious as again Gurthang managed to just pass through my dream again. He always seemed to sort of slip under, even after I began suspecting him again. Sorry I doubted you
Menel.
It's glad to see the village has won, there are a few things I would try to do differently but overall I was pleased with the way I played my first wolf game. I wish I would have went with my earliest suspicions going into night 5 on
Gurthang, but decided to choose
Durelin, luckily this mistake did not cost the death of the village.
Again, well played to all.