Quote:
|
Originally Posted by arcticstorm
Where does Tolkein get off with having Eomer actually attend the entire battle of Helm's Deep? And who is this Erkenbrand fellow? More importantly who gave him the right to add something called the "red arrow" to help summon the Rohirrim to Pellenor instead of the beakons only?
|
Yes! Exactly. Eomer...at Helm's Deep? And Haldir, he barely appears in this pesky Tolkien fellow's books. He ommision of the Elves who come to the aid of the Rohirrim is simply disgraceful. My my my...what to do, what to do...
Let us not forget Faramir's role. Tolkien left out Faramir nearly taking the Ring from Frodo and him taking them to Osgiliath. And don't even get my started on this Scouring of the Shire gibberish.
Mark my words, this Tolkien fellow will never make a name for himself.