Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim
I can't accept that Glirdan. They may have 'made up' for that by having Pippin outsmart Treebeard, but doesn't that beg an equally poignant question? Being, why was Treebeard so wishy-washy?
Well, that's three characters I'm moaning about now. Sorry!  |
It's quite alright. We're all entitled to our own opinions. Yet now I would have to agree with you
Eomer and
Kitanna. I would have rathered the Ents as they were in the book over Pippin outsmating one of the oldest beings of all of Middle Earth. It would have been better if they just went by how Grishnahk and Pippin acted in the books.