[The Saucepan Man]

Originally Posted by the phantom

It's been quiet for about three hours now.

It's too quiet. I don't like it.

That tumbleweed will be back soon.

Originally Posted by Cailín

If he's innocent, Azaelia must also be innocent - sure, she voted for Bergil, but she had to do something to prevent the doublelynching of two innocents on day 1.

I don't see how that necessarily follows. A Wolf may well want to avoid creating a double-lynching situation in order to avoid doing anything that looks suspicious. And, there were still 6 votes uncast when Azaelia voted. She may well have been waiting to vote near the deadline to try to make sure that no Wolf faced the gallows as a result of those uncast votes.

Originally Posted by Cailín

The Kath - Holbytlass connection might just be accidentical, since Holbytlass was already planning to vote for Bergil. In hindsight not the best idea, but just as likely the act of a desperate villager as of a werewolf.

Actually, I think that it's a definate possibility. As far as I can see neither of them has voiced any supicions of the other.

Originally Posted by Cailín

I still distrust Glirdan, though, even though our Cobbler seemed to have thought him innocent (or just a safe vote). He's now very suspicious of Alcarillo, because of his vote for Bergil, even though he voted for him as well... If TGWBS's death was indeed a set up by the wolves, Glirdan is definitely going along with that.

If TGWBS's death was an attempt to set up Alcarillo, then it is worth looking at those who have been gunning for Alcarillo to-Day. I would say that this applies to the following:

Gil-Galad
Azaelia
Folwren and
Glirdan.

Interesting how Glirdan's name keeps popping up whenever I try to spot potentially suspicious behaviour. Only problem is he seems the type who is easily swayed towards whatever is the current theory. Which makes him the perfect target for Wolvish manipulation ...

I'm wondering whether we should lynch Alcarillo simply because, whether he is innocent or gulity, his death will tell us more than the death of any other villager. I know it sounds harsh, but the chances are we will end up lynching an innocent to-Day anyway. The problem with that of course is that he may be gifted ...