Quote:
If Alcarillo is lynched today and found innocent, he (Glirdan) is one we should be looking at.
|
I'm not so sure. If Alca turns out to be innocent, then that would mean both of the top two vote getters yesterday were innocent- which would mean that the wolves would not have felt the need to vote for
Bergil and pad his lead over
Alca because they wouldn't care which of the two bit the dust.
Quote:
Interesting how Glirdan's name keeps popping up whenever I try to spot potentially suspicious behaviour. Only problem is he seems the type who is easily swayed towards whatever is the current theory. Which makes him the perfect target for Wolvish manipulation ...
|
Quote:
I found a similar way of behaving in some of my own posts and his constant swaying might be more the whims of a terribly confused newbie as the suspicious behavior of a werecreature
|
Quote:
As far as Glirdan is concerned I think he is just swayed by popular opinion.
|
I have the same doubts about
Glirdan's guilt that are expressed by
SPM,
Cailin, and
morm.
Quote:
I'm wondering whether we should lynch Alcarillo simply because, whether he is innocent or gulity, his death will tell us more than the death of any other villager. I know it sounds harsh, but the chances are we will end up lynching an innocent to-Day anyway. The problem with that of course is that he may be gifted ...
|
My thoughts exactly. I figured it would come to this, which is why I didn't feel the need to join in the push against Alca. I assumed his lynching was, perhaps, inevitable given the nature of the voting yesterday. It hardly matters that
tgwbs was killed by the wolves- that doesn't sway me towards Alca or away from him. To me, the best reason to lynch Alca would be to obtain information.
Of course, I'd much rather lynch someone I suspect, but my suspicions are so shallow at this point that I don't really have much of a better target to offer.
Shelob voted for me, so naturally I'd like to suspect her (though I know there's probably no true reason to).
Alca voted for a candidate he figured would get jumped on by others. This might be guilty behavior- however he is showing a lot of faith in his fellow villagers to finish the job. Would a wolf be so willing to leave things to chance? I wouldn't have myself.
Wilwa was the second to hop on the
Bergil vote. Was she a wolf trying to put an innocent safely in the lead, or an innocent figuring
we have to lynch someone, it might as well be Bergil?
Wayne stepped in and voted for
Alca, putting him into a tie with
Bergil. Was
Wayne an innocent thinking
I don't want to vote for Bergil- Alca seems like a better idea, or a wolf thinking
I think I should tie up the lead between two innocents?
Holby put
Bergil into the lead over
Kath and
Anca. Was she a wolf saving one of her fellow wolf's skin, or was she an innocent that didn't want to see a triple lynching and figured
Bergil was as good as anyone?
Azaelia's last minute vote seems a bit odd. Why vote so late for someone who already appears to be on their way to the gallows? Was she an innocent who felt it her duty to vote, and so she, not knowing in the least who to vote for, simply tacked on her vote to the favorite of the day? Or was she a wolf and felt that her fellow wolf (Alca) was too close to the lead for comfort, and wanted to pad
Bergil's total?
Any thoughts on the possibilities that I have offered?