[The Saucepan Man]

Originally Posted by Holbytlass

So for me, in this vast quagmire of theories and scenarious, will be sticking with my suspicions of Wilwarin and most likely voting for her.

Could you explain a bit more exactly why you suspect wilwa, Holby? The only reasons you have given, as far as I can see, are that she seems to be "aligning" with you (whatever that means) and her vote for Bergil (which, as I said, I find the least suspicious of the Bergil votes). That does seem to me to be rather scant evidence on which to base a vote.

Originally Posted by Kath

But I haven't really talked about her (Azaelia) because I don't find her suspicious.

Any particular reason? Her last minute "panic" vote yester-Day looks very suspicious to me.

Originally Posted by Kath

Which implies that you are suspicious of me due to this lack of solid reasoning. In that case may I please draw your eye to this post by mormegil, who used it in his reasoning for voting for me. By your logic then you would also have to be suspicious of him as this was all the reason he has given.

Hehe. I thought that you might spot that. How very observant of you. The fact is that my impression of mormegil to date is of someone trying to help out the village. Yes, he puts forward his gut instincts. But he also puts forward analysis and ideas, which is what I like to see. You, on the other hand, seemed merely to be posting your suspicions without giving us any real idea of the reasoning behind your conclusions. In short, you fitted my conception of "Wolf-like" behaviour - posting often enough not to attract suspicion as a "quiet one", but not really giving us much to work with. Meneltarmacil and Shelob also fit that pattern in my view.

Originally Posted by Kath

As to making posts that are full of substance that is difficult to do when people like the phantom, morm and SpM are around because they tend to say everything there is to say in one long post.

But there is nothing to stop you saying whether you agree or disagree with what we (or any of the villagers) are saying and, if so, why.

Having said that, I am grateful to you for your further explanation of why you find Menel suspicious. That sort of thing is much more helpful.

Originally Posted by Menel

He (Folwren) then jumps at yet another idea, this being the SpM/Phantom-as-wolves suggestion by mormegil.

Actually, I rather got the impression that he was challenging morm's suggestion.

A further thought on the idea of lynching Alcarillo for the information it will tell us. One drawback, if most villagers vote for him, is that to-Day's vote would then tell us very little, particularly if he turns out to be innocent. I have no objection to Alcarillo being lynched because, either way, I think that it will tell us a lot. But I certainly would not want to see all the votes go his way. Much better to spread the votes around in an effort to force the Wolves into doing something which might give them away.