[Cailín]

Originally Posted by Kath

I see. Well all I can say to that is I am not clever enough to carry it out nor brave enough to attempt it! If I were the Bear and had tried that I strongly suspect that I would be dead by now!

The funny thing is, you would not be. Nobody's going after the bear today and I don't think you are a real wolf-lynching candidate either. I'm not saying that you really are the bear, because, honestly, I have absolutely no clue as to who the bear is.

Folwren - I must say she confuses me. (...) To be honest I am not sure that she is guilty, she could just be a little confused or freaked out by all the accusing going on, but I'd like to hear some explanations from her quite soon.

Agreed. Her contributions haven't really been helpful up till now, but they were enough to make me not suspect her. She voted Alca yesterday, following the phantom's plan to clear things up a little, yet accuses the exact same people she accused from day one - without solid reasoning.

Shelob - We haven't really heard much from her but what she has said has been quite helpful. That comment about the wolves killing one of a pair of adversaries is a good one. Are they trying to frame the survivor or are they playing a clever double bluff?

SpM and the phantom clearly seemed allies in this game - at least to me. Sure, they did argue, but rather to edge on the rest of us (and possibly to amuse themselves a little). It was quite evident the phantom never suspected SpM and SpM was just a little on guard. So trying to frame the survivor seems incredibly far-fetched. Nobody's suspecting SpM anymore than yesterday. If it's a clever double bluff and The Saucepan Man is, in fact, a wolf, someone save us...?

---

What catches my eye the most is that both the wolves and the bear are killing as much experienced players as possible. Being a newbie myself, I am (or at least am considered) easily manipulated and easy to fool. TGWBS, Kitanna, Morm, the phantom all were experienced players. Without these people - who were also regular contributors - the village will become a lot easier to infiltrate by the werecreatures. I'm still suspicious of others I consider very experienced who are saying too little to be accused, like Shelob and Holbytlass.

Now I'm hoping the bear might still be on our side for now. But tis funny that the bear should choose to kill Mormegil rather than Glirdan or Azaelia who seem to be the main suspects today. So I think with the bear we should be looking at someone who does not agree with the public opinion - or someone far too clever for their own good.

We have fourteen people left, three are wolves. Two out of 14 are known innocents, at least for me ^^. The people under the most suspicion right now are Glirdan, Azaelia and Meneltarmacil. Now, do we honestly believe these three are our wolves, or would that just be too easy?

Originally Posted by Meneltarmacil

I'd say we're dealing with some rather intelligent werebeasts here, finding the Seer this early on.

I notice that Azaelia's vote did put Bergil in the majority when the deadline was close and both he and Glirdan were about to be lynched. She does seem a little wolfish to me, but I think her defense of herself makes sense as well and therefore I'm going to reserve judgement for now.

Glirdan, though, seems to have changed his mind on a lot of things and several people voted for him yesterDay. I think he may be up to something.

Is Meneltarmacil really flattering himself here? When I'm looking through his posts I really find nothing suspicious there. Only perhaps that he voted Azaelia, and at a crucial time too, while feeling so strongly about Glirdan earlier. It makes a Glirdan - Azaelia - Menel team very unlikely. Kath, I may have missed something here, I apologize - but why exactly do you find Menel so suspicious? His voting behavior - as SpM rightly points out - has not been so strange either. Only if Azaelia is not a wolf, Menel just may be one.

Right now, I think Glirdan is the most suspicious in his behavior. Azaelia has a similar record, but I find that her defense is just slightly better. It seems that on Day 1, she prevented a doublelynching by making a desperate last minute vote and day two, she was just unlucky, jumping on the wrong bandwagon. I'm not saying she's innocent, I'm still wary about her, but I'm inclined to vote Glirdan tonight.

---

I'm not feeling at my most helpful-ishness either and I have this strong, bad feeling that once we know who the wolves are, I'm going to pull my hair out of frustration. *sniff* I mean, what do I know? I'm just the girl who crochets scarves, you know.