Quote:
|
Hmph. It's awfully infuriating when I set up circumstances to be perfectly in my favor but a random chance ruins everything.
|
It wasn't random chance there friend...we killed you simply because you were too smart for our own good and we couldn't figure out what you meant by talking about who the wolves should kill.
It looked like you were setting up a trap for us. If you were and you were alive after to explain it we'd have died. By killing you we insured you couldn't explain it (if you had a plan) and that we'd be safe from your analyzing (in either case). End of Story.
That's why we chose you over our suspected seer. We figured you were more of an immediate threat and that if the seer already had one werewolf pegged (since it looked like were Holby the seer she'd dreamt of Wilwa) that werewolf would be just as dead whether we killed the seer that night or the next.
Quote:
|
I looked back through day one to see if Morm pointed at someone as being his pal, or if someone else pointed at Morm. And I found someone- Glirdan.
|
When you made that hint to Saucepan Man I figured you'd either caught a gifted or one of us. So I went back and looked at all the posts of the people on SPM's list. I noticed the same thing you did with Glirdan (though I didn't
know that Menel was actually a sherrif, so mine was much more of an assumption), but I also noticed one of the few clues that Glirdan was the bear.
Quote:
Theory #2
In post #82 in the thread Glirdan says
Quote:
|
As for the Llama, I like llama's. They're cute and cuddly and I would never do anything to harm Shelob.
|
I'm not sure, but I believe by that point in the game the only two people accused of being the bear (the one to kill the llama) were Menel (by Folwern) and Phantom (by whomever). Also Glirdan had barely mentioned me, he mentions me when he picks up and begins to push the Wayne thing, and again in that post when he says he thinks I'm innocent. It's possible to read this as a paranoia induced response from the bear, I don't think it's particularly likely though...but it's worth considering.
|
I didn't think it was likely 'cause I assumed he and Menel were the sherrifs, once it was clear Glirdan wasn't the sherrif (after Nilp revealed himself) I'd forgotten about it. Which was annoying 'cause had I remembered I probably could have gotten us one more night of a double kill...but now I'm glad I caught something you missed
, even if I couldn't put it to use
.
Quote:
|
If you are innocent and clueless then you should be suspicious of everyone, but Shelob was the exact opposite. She seemed to be willing to give everyone the benefit of the doubt. I figured she was trying to stay on everyone's good side.
|
Actually...I can't see suspiciousness in people. I naturally give everyone the benefit of the doubt. Just like I'm not naturally talkative/outgoing. I seem to be naturally inclined to act in a really suspicous way. Go Figure.
In short: Nice write up.