[Kuruharan]

...now I kind of like them.

Anguirel- In his favor it can be said that (in some ways) he was less strange. He was at least present and offering ideas. However, the way he behaved was still odd (as I believe I observed at the time). He requires watching. I certainly would not object to a serious inquisition…uhh, I mean investigation into him toDAY.

Azaelia- Still hard to get a read on. She did help break up the possible double lynch. (phantom read this next bit) I’m not too suspicious of her at this moment.

Boromir88- I am more suspicious of him toDAY than I was yesterDAY. I don’t suspect him too much, but he is definitely on the radar. Playing a prominent role in lynching an innocent is never a good thing. I’m also beginning to find his not finding anything useful in DAY ONE’s voting suspicious. It almost seems like he didn’t want anybody else to find anything there.

Spawn- I’m wary of her. Didn’t say a whole lot to get noticed yesterDAY. This causes the alarms to go off in my head. Needs watching. The relative paucity of things I have to say about her is also worrying.

Eonwe- Suspicious. Does not explain anything. Just acts and expects others to follow along. Later actions will sometimes contradict earlier actions and still no explanation is given. This is very suspicious behavior. Requires watching and may require a vote.

Gil-Galad- Strange. Unhelpful. Suicidal. In some ways the village would be better off if he were dead even if he is a villager. He’s hanging over us like a cloud. And now he is being weird again.

Kitanna- Still suspicious. She early and repeatedly voiced suspicions about Wayne (posts 142, 155). However, on the other hand, so was most everybody else. She was, perhaps, initially more consistent about it. Her behavior at the end of yesterDAY is open to a little interpretation. She will, of course, say that she was attempting to offer Marcolië an opportunity. Even so it nearly caused a mess. I still think she requires watching.

Kuruharan- Innocent. Was one of the first (after our Seer of blessed memory) to say I thought Glirdan was innocent. Argued on DAY ONE against lynching Azaelia, even though that would have been a very safe vote for a werewolf. I was not comfortable with the choice presented to us on DAY TWO (as I said in post 216) but was driven into that choice by necessity. Even so, on DAY TWO I did everything I could to prevent another double lynching, even to the point of voting for Wayne last (and slightly unnecessarily) both to drive home the point of avoiding another double lynching and just to be on the safe side.

Lalaith- Suspicious. Unfortunately, nobody else seems to share my view of her. Never really contributes anything that original to the discussion and hardly ever comments at all. She may be attempting to position herself to try and have me lynched and then when it is seen that I am innocent say something to the effect of, “well he started it.” I really wish some other people would take a serious look at her.

Marcolië Lamen- She is now on my Suspicious list. Seems helpful. However, this almost makes me uneasy. Was involved in that silly farce with Anguriel. Was also involved in the situation that almost lead to a double lynching.

the phantom- Suspicious. He derided me most of the DAY yesterDAY for criticizing his voting on DAY ONE until I carefully explained to him the werewolf strategy I thought he might have been employing. He suddenly shut up about that. He also seemed to want to spend most of yesterDAY arguing with me about the status of the Seer’s dream and Azaelia, even though I repeatedly tried to point out that it wasn’t really relevant to the DAY’s discussion. He also accused me of wanting to lynch Azaelia, which I repeatedly said I didn’t. He also showed one or two traces of the old “hysterical phantom under fire” routine (posts 163, 208) but this may speak in his favor…or it might not. First to actually vote for Wayne yesterDAY, although people had been threatening for some time. I’m not convinced he’s a wolf (partly because I think it depends on Eonwe) but I do not like the way he has been acting.

What are we going to do about Gil-Galad?

I think we need to look at the people who were involved in that little ruckus at the end of the vote yesterDAY (yes, that includes myself) because we nearly had another fiasco and I think at least one wolf was possibly involved in it. However, it may also just have been due to circumstances beyond our control since Gil-Galad was pretty far ahead when votes started to roll in for Wayne and you could not expect Wayne to vote for himself.

Those of us were:
Kuruharan
Kitanna
Márcolië Laman
Azaelia

I think Kitanna and Márcolië Laman make more likely wolf candidates, but I’m not sure about either.

Also we might want to comb through Celuien’s posts to see if there is anything there to glean about who might have benefited from getting rid of her or if there is a discernable reason.

Again I reserve the right to change this at the drop of a hat.