Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Glirdan
I don't know why you want to get rid of someone so valiant!!! You are all insane!! He got hit with a Southron poison arrow and lived which not a whole lot of men could probably accomplish, even if they had help from a King of Numenorean descent!! You're all crazy!!!! I say be rid of Grishnahk. Not only is he getting into the food, but he's also now starting fights in the camp with others!!! He HAS to go!!!!
|
Getting hit with an arrow is not a sign of valour! It's a sign of good marksmanship on the part of the archer! How on earth is this an indication of Faramir possessing a sterling quality? Aragorn cured a great number of people that night, so your argument about not anyone recovering is null and void!
And if you're voting off people getting into the food, then I highly recommend Merry and Pippin. Those two can out-eat Grishnakh anyday.