[Hiriel]

Eek. I get on late thinking to find Feanor gone and TORE's logic still among us. This is a gutstaber and no mistake. *sighs* Can't be on long, but here's my thoughts:

Innocents
Feanor: TORE trusted him impicitly, and he's admitted to being the ranger. If we doubt Fea, then we're back to square one.

Jack: Was protected by Fea the night no one died, so long as we trust Fea. Which I do, at any rate. The wolves don't turn on each other, at least not at night. Jack's innocent.

Hiriel: Well, I know I'm innocent, but to prove it the rest of ya'll, I cite that both Fea and TORE (even though Fea did not in fact dream of me, he backed up TORE, who could have) counted me as completely, proven innocent. Why would they do that if they had doubts about me? Why not just say they didn't suspect me at the time? I also tied the vote between Sleepy and Bergil when there were still more votes for Sleepy. If I was a wolf, I could have saved Bergil from the noose. A wolf, while the vote was still up in the air, wouldn't vote for another wolf.

Sleepy Ranger: What clears him in my mind is that he was the first person to vote, and vote correctly for a wolf. Why would he not try to, if he was a wolf, cast suspicion on someone else the whole day? Or use his vote to try and build a bandwagon for one of the innocents? I could understand if it looked as though Bergil was going to be hanged all along and there was not any real hope of saving him, SleepyRanger!Wolf voting for Bergil to save his identity, but I can't see a wolf casting unnessisary suspicion on a fellow wolf who was certainly on people's list, but wasn't likely to be hanged when SR voted. EDIT Also what Sleepy said in defense of himself. I'd forgoten TORE asked the Seer to dream about him.

Probable Innocents:
Rune: He's been very logical the whole game, his voting pattern is pretty solid and he looks to me unwolfish. Now, I haven't seen anything that would clear him entirely, but he's not at all my top suspect. Rune's only quirk is that he keeps gunning for Thinlomien, who I haven't seen much evidence for, one way or the other. I dunno why that is, Rune's not the Seer, but maybe I'm missing something.

Thinlomien: This is gut feeling. I've not seen any damning evidence for Thin, other than the lack of votes. As for those, I accept Thin's reasons why he was confused. Lord knows that could have been me, if I wasn't so bored on Day 1. I've not seen anything to clear Thin entirely, but I'm 70% sure.

Now, that leaves Malkatoj and Eonwe. Eonwe...I'm now about 55% sure that Eonwe's a wolf. All the points SR brought up make sense to me. I'd already had in mind Bergil's assertation of Eonwe's innocence early on. I've just seen less redeeming points on Eonwe's part. He voted late for Bergil, and even though he broke the tie between Sleepy and Bergil, it was pretty clear that Jack ( who voted last) was going to vote for Bergil anyway. Also: TORE voted for Eonwe Day 1. He said it was for completely baseless reasons, however, I doubt TORE did anything in this game that was baseless. He couldn't very well have said, "Um, guys, I had a dream last night that Eonwe was really hairy."

As for Malk, our Seer was sure in counting Malkatoj as a wolf, and I trust TORE. So, even though I might weigh in on whatever comes up later on today, I want to vote early.

++Malkatoj