Doh! We shouldn't have voted off Saeros!
Although, I am glad that we did, because I can't stand him.
The principal candidates seem to have been identified.
Melian: A moderating influence on Thingol. However, my impression is that he would still have looked favourably on Turin, given the opportunity, even without her counsel.
Mablung and
Beleg: Not the only Elves who were friendly to Turin in Doriath. Probably made his life there easier, but were more instrumental in providing him with help and friendship after he had left Doriath.
Finduilas: Not sure how here removal will make his life more difficult while he is still in Doriath.
Morwen and
Nienna: Well we surely can't lose Nienna now, but I can see how the removal of Turin's mother would heighten his concern for his sister, and therefore his angst levels, while in Doriath.
Morwen seems like a good candidate to me, although I expect
Lalaith to oppose her removal.
As an alternative, I'd be happy to vote for whichever candidate would, by his or her removal, annoy
Anguirel the most.
Problem is, it's difficult to work up an argument for any of his favourites ...
Unless, the eviction of someone like
Curufin might be seen as removing a buffer against Morgoth's forces, thereby threatening the security of Doriath and making it less of a "safe haven" for Turin. Any thoughts on that from anyone?
PS I am still mourning the loss of Huan. If only I had been around to stick up for him. How could you all vote off such a loyal, faithful and intelligent hound.
