I thank you all. I had forgotten about heliador when I posted my query. My point has been opposed and thoroughly defeated, but you must admit that my conclusion of peridot was a good one, given the circumstances of my mind when I wrote this. So Aragorn did find a beryl. It was indeed an elf-stone, but it would have perfect if I had been correct about my wraith-warding peridot ideas. I apologize for making it seem as if a beryl and an emerald are one and the same- I know otherwise and I would have clarified had I not been ousted from my work before I was finished. Thanks once again.
|