[Gothmog]

Actually, Thinlomien, I didn't have anything special in mind. But the thought of her singing with the other's feels to strange. At the same time, if she wasn't created at the creation of Arda (which she obviously wasn't), I prefer to think of her as one of Ainur, created by Eru. Why would Eru force her to sing? Let's assume she had a dark heart from the start and dwelled in the void far from the others. If she then decide not to participate in the singing then what would Eru win by forcing her? A destructive force in the creation of Arda?

But maybe she decided to join in the choir. There were voices that joined Melkor in his own melodies. She could have been corrupted during this singing. "In the beginning she was one of those that he corrupted to his service." (look at post quotes below for full extract from silm.) Then she decided to stay in the void outside the world and not descend in to it immidietly. She might have dwelt in the Void before and after the creation of Arda.

Does any of this make sense? I'm not really fit for this right now... And yeah, let's discuss the "unknown forces of Arda" a year or two